A Baker's Guide to Choosing the Perfect Dutch Oven for Sourdough

Cast Iron Bread Oven with Cloche Lid

Ready to up your bread game? I'm going to help you choose the right Dutch oven for baking amazing sourdough bread. 

Why Use a Dutch Oven?

First, let's talk about why a Dutch oven is such a game-changer for sourdough baking. Think of it as having a professional bakery oven right in your kitchen. The secret? Steam. When your dough enters a preheated Dutch oven, the moisture in the dough transforms into steam, keeping the surface soft so it can expand and rise properly – what bakers call "oven spring." While the inside becomes light and airy, that steamy environment helps develop a thin, crackly crust. Without a Dutch oven, the steam would escape, resulting in a denser loaf with a tougher, chewier crust.

Choosing the Right Size

Size matters when it comes to Dutch ovens. Use one that's too small, and your dough might hit the lid as it rises, creating a squished loaf. 

Here are my size recommendations：

Basic Size Guidelines

  • For round boules (500g flour): 4-5 liters (4-5 quarts)
  • For oval batards (500g flour): 5-7 liters (5-7 quarts)
  • Minimum depth requirement: 4-5 inches (10-12 cm)
  • Ideal all-around size: 5.5 quarts

Size-Specific Uses

  • 3-quart: Works for smaller recipes with adjustments
  • 4-quart: Good for standard round loaves
  • 4.5-quart: Versatile size for most recipes
  • 5-quart: Ideal for standard sourdough
  • 7-quart: Best for larger loaves and batards

Family Size Considerations

A good rule of thumb is to plan for one quart per person, then round up. For example:

  • Family of 4: Minimum 4 quarts, ideal 5-6 quarts
  • Family of 6: Minimum 6 quarts, ideal 7 quarts

Space Requirements

Here's a simple test to ensure proper sizing: your proofing basket should fit inside the Dutch oven with approximately 1 inch of space around the edges. This space allows the dough to expand properly during baking.

Types of Dutch Ovens

Let's break down the different options:

  1. Enameled Dutch Ovens: These classic pieces come in beautiful colors with smooth, light-colored enamel interiors. Look for one with a heavy base for even heat distribution, a snug-fitting lid to trap steam, an oven-safe knob, and sturdy handles – you'll be moving this in and out of a hot oven, after all.
  2. Combi Cookers (or Double Dutch Ovens): These versatile pieces feature a skillet bottom and a pot that fits over the top. The Lodge combo cooker is particularly popular among sourdough bakers. One advantage is that when you remove the lid for the final bake, the loaf sides are more exposed, promoting extra browning and crisping.
  3. Cast Iron Bread Pans: These newer additions to the scene are known for creating exceptional crusts. They're quite heavy and require some muscle to handle, but if you're serious about your crust, they're worth considering.

For sourdough, I recommend sticking with cast iron options rather than stainless steel or ceramic Dutch ovens, as they provide superior heat retention and distribution.

Safety First

Handling a heavy, hot Dutch oven can be intimidating. Always use high-temperature oven gloves – not flimsy oven mitts. Consider using a bread sling – a heat-resistant silicone fabric that helps you lower the dough into the Dutch oven and lift it out safely.

Maintenance Tips

For enameled Dutch ovens that develop brown stains, try:

  • Baking soda and vinegar paste
  • Magic eraser
  • Barkeeper's Friend
  • Soft scouring pad
  • Or, surprisingly, the dishwasher (though I'd be cautious with high-end models)

For cast iron Dutch ovens, prevent rust by drying thoroughly after washing and maintaining a protective oil coating.

With these insights, you're ready to choose the perfect Dutch oven and start your sourdough baking adventure. Whether you're planning to try a double-fermented loaf, experiment with multi-grain recipes, or develop your own signature sourdough, the possibilities are endless. Happy baking!

Back to blog